Toggle Accessibility Tools

The limits of photosynthetic efficiency

Increasing the efficiency of the ATP synthase could lead to ROS production. This has important implications for synthetic biology efforts to alter photosynthetic efficiency by engineering the ATP synthase.


Figure of c ring variations and effect on photosynthesis

Scientific Achievement

Experimental and computational studies demonstrated that increasing the efficiency of one energy storing reaction in photosynthesis will likely lead to production of deleterious reactive oxygen species in others. To cope with these trade-offs, Nature has tuned photosynthesis to balance the needs for efficient and safe energy storage.

Significance and Impact

It has been proposed that genetically modifying the protein subunit stoichiometry for the chloroplast ATP synthase could lead to substantial increases in the efficiency of photosynthesis. We show that this strategy will likely fail because it leads to photodamage and loss of yield. Instead, our work suggests a new engineering approach that increases efficiency while avoiding deleterious side reactions.

Research Details

  • Photosynthesis uses light to store energy in a redox gradient and an electrochemical proton gradient (proton motive force, pmf), which drives the synthesis of ATP through the thylakoid FoF1-ATP synthase. ATP synthase structure and function are conserved across biological kingdoms, but the number of ion–binding c subunits varies between organisms, which alters the proton/ATP ratio, with implications for metabolism. Essentially, the c-ring size sets the “gear ratio” of photosynthesis, and it has been suggested that decreasing their size, or increasing the gear ratio, could improve photosynthetic efficiency.
  • However our experiments and simulations predict that the change in energy storage will cause large increases in pmf, destabilizing charge separated states in photosystem II, leading to production of reactive oxygen species. Thus, the large c-ring size may be optimized to prevent photodamage. This has important implications for the evolution and regulation of photosynthesis as well as for synthetic biology efforts to alter photosynthetic efficiency by engineering the ATP synthase.
  • We propose that engineering efforts be focused instead on adjusting the storage of pmf and the energy storing reactions of PSII to prevent recombination.

Related people: Geoffry Davis, David M. Kramer (CA) 

DOI: 10.3389/fpls.2019.01778

Download the highlight

This work was primarily funded by the US Department of Energy, Office of Basic Energy Sciences.

Top Stories

Understanding how algal cells divide when they are hungry Understanding how algal cells divide when they are hungry

A new study delves into how algae manage cell division processes when they suffer from starvation. The finding has implications for biofuel technologies, given that algae have the potential to become a sustainable source of high value oils.

2020 Anton Lang Memorial Award winners announced 2020 Anton Lang Memorial Award winners announced

Kellie Walters and Bryan Ferlez were both recognized as scientists who exemplify the research excellence, ideas, dedication, and vision of former PRL director, Anton Lang.

Beronda Montgomery named MSU Office of Research & Innovation interim assistant vice president [LINK] Beronda Montgomery named MSU Office of Research & Innovation interim assistant vice president [LINK]

MSU Foundation Professor, Beronda Montgomery, will bring her talents to the Office of Research & Innovation as interim assistant vice president. She joined the team in a half-time capacity effective Sept. 15, 2020.